Fisheries department rots from the top

DJP

Sealiner
A factional war lays bare a culture of corruption

FULL ARTICLE AT

https://www.groundup.org.za/article/fisheries-department-rots-top/

South Africa’s fisheries authority is in a state of crisis, paralysed by a factional war between its two most senior officials and hollowed out by a culture of corruption.

This has left the Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries (DAFF) unable to perform many of its most basic tasks, including allocating fishing rights and enforcing regulations. An exodus of skilled staff, including top scientists, has aggravated the problem.

As a consequence, the fisheries sector, a critical pillar of the Western Cape’s economy, is plagued by deep disfunction, a state of affairs that disproportionately affects poor people. Government programs intended to uplift fishing communities — now hotbeds for abalone and crayfish poaching — have repeatedly stalled.

The rot at the department, entrenched for many years, has been laid bare by a power struggle between director-general Mike Mlengana and his deputy, Siphokazi Ndudane. Even the minister for the department, Senzeni Zokwana, has become embroiled in the dispute, siding with Ndudane.

Over the last 18 months, their rift has played out in a bewildering sequence of suspensions, court cases and accusations of criminality. Reporters, law firms, unions and opposition politicians have been drawn into the fray, sometimes unwittingly being used for factional agendas.

The department has spent tens of millions of rands on legal fees for both officials, in some cases hiring opposing sets of counsel. In the last two years, the department has also commissioned at least three forensic reports into corruption, although even these have been tainted by allegations of improper influence.

From both sides, there are claims that the department has been “captured” by private interests, ranging from tenderpreneurs to abalone poaching syndicates. In this series we review the evidence, based on court records, internal documents and more than a dozen interviews.

:X:X:X:X
 

mrcricket

Member
Had a quick read on another site....what an absolute mess. Corruption is rife,our fisheries dwindling and Im pretty sure that sooner rather than later the Asian countries will flash cash and they’ll be harvesting in our backyards. If its not already happening.
We need a resolution asap.
 

Limpopoking

Sealiner
This is but one government dept... The same can be said for just about every dept, our SOEs and our state funded organisations (I use the term "organisation" sparingly). SA has become a hollowed out shell, the shell kept intact by the hopelessly overburdened taxpayer. It's not even vaguely sustainable.
 

Serra Moz

Sealiner
LOL... I don't even wanna get involved in this nasty debate... Rotten from the top....cadres that's never seen the sea in their life for starters... And the poor suffers, the people that should have the rights.. Me OVER AND OUT!
 

DocPhil

Senior Member
And China stands ready to pounce on your lucrative fragile fish stocks, they have been getting into fisheries from Vanuatu to Angola...
 

Serra Moz

Sealiner
DocPhil wrote:
And China stands ready to pounce on your lucrative fragile fish stocks, they have been getting into fisheries from Vanuatu to Angola...

100% correct even Congo (Pointe Noire) - have a fleet of like 15 + trawlers, prawns and and, direct export to China (or indirect import ???? LOL)

Seen them active at Gabon too..
 

Envor

Senior Member
Thank you for submitting your letter in response to the article:
Fisheries department rots from the top.
The title of your letter is:
Sad state of affairs at the Department of Fisheries
A GroundUp editor will make a decision whether to publish it or not within two working days.
If we publish the letter, it may be edited for typos, grammar and style. The title may also be changed.
We will communicate with you via this email address: ehassiem@telkomsa.net.
Here is the text of your letter:
Dear Editor
It’s with utmost dismay that I’m reading this article.
As a child we grew up with the abalone resources being plentiful and for all too enjoy if you stay within the required limits per day and size taken. All of a sudden a little birdie said that consuming dried abalone will give a man real power in bed. Off course if your appearance is as narrow as a razor blade you tend to believe such sh!t. I for once can’t recall that after consuming abalone did it had or made an effect on my libido or that of my forefathers.
These are all mindsets that has to be changed.
One day we only be able to show a Google image of a abalone to our grandchildren.
Until we placed a total ban on our resources will this looting and cahooting continue for years to come until nothing’s left.
I also hope the country leaders appoint people in positions with morals values. Education nowadays are cheap on the internet. You are able to attain an MA degree for a few rand but morally you are rotten to the core. That doesn’t help the country and it’s resources if you willing to accept monies backhand for deals to attain flashy suits and shoes.
Sincerely
Envor Hassiem
 

Serra Moz

Sealiner
Envor wrote:
Thank you for submitting your letter in response to the article:
Fisheries department rots from the top.
The title of your letter is:
Sad state of affairs at the Department of Fisheries
A GroundUp editor will make a decision whether to publish it or not within two working days.
If we publish the letter, it may be edited for typos, grammar and style. The title may also be changed.
We will communicate with you via this email address: ehassiem@telkomsa.net.
Here is the text of your letter:
Dear Editor
It’s with utmost dismay that I’m reading this article.
As a child we grew up with the abalone resources being plentiful and for all too enjoy if you stay within the required limits per day and size taken. All of a sudden a little birdie said that consuming dried abalone will give a man real power in bed. Off course if your appearance is as narrow as a razor blade you tend to believe such sh!t. I for once can’t recall that after consuming abalone did it had or made an effect on my libido or that of my forefathers.
These are all mindsets that has to be changed.
One day we only be able to show a Google image of a abalone to our grandchildren.
Until we placed a total ban on our resources will this looting and cahooting continue for years to come until nothing’s left.
I also hope the country leaders appoint people in positions with morals values. Education nowadays are cheap on the internet. You are able to attain an MA degree for a few rand but morally you are rotten to the core. That doesn’t help the country and it’s resources if you willing to accept monies backhand for deals to attain flashy suits and shoes.
Sincerely
Envor Hassiem

LOL... Well said!
 

DJP

Sealiner
I'm honestly fed up with the state of affairs, yet I still pay in excess of R500 (fishing, spearfishing, bait, crayfish, boat fishing, cast net...) a year just for permits. When I get to the beach I often see poachers of signs of poaching during broad daylight, people taking out bait in MPAs, people keeping over their quota or undersize fish... no policing. The only people that ever checked my permits were in the Southern Cape, Cape Nature officials, that actually know what they are doing and care about the environment they are suppose to manage (I'm pretty sure the permit money never sees their pockets).

I have grown up in a conservation minded family that loved to go abalone and crayfish diving (fishing in later years), and now it's being run into the ground by pathetic department... better yet I don't have access to these resources anymore, a real wtf moment...

Why are we so reluctant to do anything about it?

Why aren't any of the larger institutions e.g. fishing clubs etc standing up for their rights?

Why are we still paying for permits... funding the obviously corrupt?
 

Pylstert

Sealiner
It seems like a free for all, poachers have now moved in to the Simon's Town area, they dive in broad daylight often in groups of up to 20 and this with the Naval base right there and the useless DAFF boats parked there. In Kalk Bay harbour everything gets kept and carried away right past the inspector's caravan. Or recreationals come and off load their tuna and sell it in the harbour also right in front of the "inspectors"
 

willem wikkel spies

Moderator
Staff member
it is a sad state of affairs.

the fishing industry is more then a billion a year.

you guys need to understand where they come from.

they do think, that a million rand will last a life time.....

so they will also think that the resources will last a life time.

SAPS are understaffed.
those who are there, need to attend to the priority crimes!!!

fishing/ poaching of fish is not a priority crime.

and then the illegal trawl netters.....well someone needs to make money!!!

lets hope they do get their house in order.
 
Many problems, the rot starts from the top..but the fixing will come from us from the bottom..

I have faith, smart people are already at work in working out ways in helping in constructive ways to fix this..

Tuna recromercials able to apply for limited commercial licenses if their vessels have the correct storage facility for keeping the catch on ice and they take care of the catch properly. Similarly small boats should be able to apply for limited commercial licences for sustainable pelagics and bait/squid etc. When boats are netting tons of whatever, poling hundreds of tuna and taking tons each night of squid, a 20kg squid license or a 5-10 tuna a boat license would not dent the stock and local markets can get supplied instead of just spain and asia. Slot limits should be introduced. Government hatcheries should be restocking the sea with cob, geelbek, gallies, perlies etc..and employing fresh graduates looking for jobs. We should be conservatively and constructively ranching the coast with local equity ownership and not raping it. There should be some actual policing, only having my license checked once in my life, also in southern cape. Never having my catch checked in my life. But what does it matter when there is a commercial out there with a fill the boat licence with no slot limit, or a licence to net entire stocks from the beach when conditions force them there, a lot has to change. There must be management of the stocks for the future for the benefit of the masses. Recreational fishing money is worth way more than commercial money, but gov' priorities commercial interests. Easier to milk the gravy train of commercial interests though and turn a blind eye to long term consequences.
But times are changing ;).

With the other news conglomerate major shareholders in the the rotten commercial fishing sector, you don't read much of the rot.. News24/naspers needs a pat on the back!
 

BTTB

Senior Member
DJP wrote:
I'm honestly fed up with the state of affairs, yet I still pay in excess of R500 (fishing, spearfishing, bait, crayfish, boat fishing, cast net...) a year just for permits. When I get to the beach I often see poachers of signs of poaching during broad daylight, people taking out bait in MPAs, people keeping over their quota or undersize fish... no policing. The only people that ever checked my permits were in the Southern Cape, Cape Nature officials, that actually know what they are doing and care about the environment they are suppose to manage (I'm pretty sure the permit money never sees their pockets).

I have grown up in a conservation minded family that loved to go abalone and crayfish diving (fishing in later years), and now it's being run into the ground by pathetic department... better yet I don't have access to these resources anymore, a real wtf moment...

Why are we so reluctant to do anything about it?

Why aren't any of the larger institutions e.g. fishing clubs etc standing up for their rights?

Why are we still paying for permits... funding the obviously corrupt?
Its a case of DAFF fiddles while Rome burns!

I swear DAFF spend more time checking out these almost worthless permits (Angling R78 pa) just to make it look as if they are doing something.
 
In regards to Abalone, the Red Boat lays on anchor wherever it goes, seemingly doing nothing, occasionally sending out a rubber duck to check recreational fishing permits if recreational boats are in the area.
Somebody please explain what it costs per day to run these red boats and what successes can be contributed to them actually making a difference in regards to poaching etc.

In no way do I wish to discount the recreational fishing permit, but what can R78 pa do in the bigger scheme of things. In general recreational fisherman are self regulating.

Did you know its illegal to wear a wetsuit between Pearly Beach and Gansbaai Harbour. This law has not helped one bit in stopping poaching. All it achieved was denied the average resident the ability to swim, surf or spear with a wetsuit. The poachers dive during the day in full view of the residents in full violation of the wetsuit rule not to mention the very illegal reason they are diving in the first place.

My view is that Perlemoen are like Snails in your garden ..... you can clear snails out and in time they return with a vengeance. Abalone is also being bred by the millions every day at the many Abalone Farms along the Overstrand Area. These 2 points echo the view that the species can reproduce quickly in captivity or in the wild.
The problem for me the gross violation of the all other sea life, meaning at each incident where Abalone is removed from the sea, it leaves a trail of destruction for other shelled creatures and screws up the whole food chain for other species who require the balance of nature to feed off.
If you keep removing the Abalone from the rocks, it will eventually be crowded out by kelp for instance. Fish species who look for things to eat off the rocks will be forced to find other places to feed.

In Knysna they gave a few locals Oyster permits and within a season or two using crowbars they scraped the rocks clear of all shell life at spring low tides.
The destruction is so obvious to see along that coastline where the inshore rocks are devoid of sea life.
 

_zaahid

Member
what's the possibility of us as the sealine community taking this further, approaching other clubs and standing together to fight this misconduct. It is our sport, we are all Law abiding citizens and we live in a democratic country. The voice of the community is what governs us, we should take a stand against this.

At minimum we could create a petition on this site and get signatures for it, The petition would be for gaining our rights back as fisherman, and stricter officials on all our beaches, not only our MPA's
 

Pylstert

Sealiner
_zaahid wrote:
what's the possibility of us as the sealine community taking this further, approaching other clubs and standing together to fight this misconduct. It is our sport, we are all Law abiding citizens and we live in a democratic country. The voice of the community is what governs us, we should take a stand against this.
At minimum we could create a petition on this site and get signatures for it, The petition would be for gaining our rights back as fisherman, and stricter officials on all our beaches, not only our MPA's

There is this organisation http://mapu.org.za/ not sure if they operate nationally?
 
Top