To be honest a chisel nose has never and will never be MY first choice for garrick. Dropshot is WAY more versatile!!!! You can change retrieve a bit with plugs, whereas with dropshots you can retrieve it however you like, skipping the surface or twitching on the bottom. I have caught garrick on all types of retrieves, if they are not taking the fast retrieves then slow it right down and you can then also catch kob, flathead and shad which I have also caught in the seekoei on dropshot.
If you watch the Alcock dvd where they target garrick from the boat, Chad mentions that if they were using a leadhead (/dropshot, same difference) they would have boated 6 of them already. They were using spook type lures just because the take (when they eventually commit) is cool to see. When they did use the leadhead, their retrieve was slow and on the bottom. If there is weed in the water then I go somewhere else lol
dropshots to use in seekoei river - white, pearl variations and the kob like chartreuse. 3-4inch is good.
My pb garrick was caught in the middle of winter, in July. That was in the sea and not river, where they are pretty much all year round