Farmed vs Local bait (Non-ed)

RuanJ

Member
Hello Sealine

Net vir interessantheid, hoe vergelyk "farmed" geelstert wat mense in bait shops kry teenoor die geelstert wat uit ons waters kom in terme van olie/bloed en kwaliteit van die vleis?

Het julle al 'n duidelike verskil observeer tussen farmed en local? Wat beveel julle aan en hoekom?

Dan wil ek graag weet hoe vergelyk Katonkel/Sarda teenoor Geelstert in terme van olie inhoud en bloed?

Dankie julle.::slr::
 

willem wikkel spies

Moderator
Staff member
dis n strik vraag wat min manne die andwoord sal kan gee.

die groot geheim is net om n aas in die water te he.
twedens, olie "smell" speel wel n belangrike rol.
die groot geheim is om daai olie stadig maar seker uit die aas te laat Verdun in die water in.

so n aas wat al 5 ure le, sal minder aantrekings krag he as n vars aas wat nou net ingesit is.

so, soms moet n mens, al is aas steeds moii, hom met n vars bloeiende een vervang.

dis dieselfde wanneer ons lewendige aas hengel, n vars vissie wat mooi skop, trek baie meer aandag as n ou moee vissie.

self live bait het slym en olie, en dit ward afgegee in die water.
teen die tyd wat die aas vis moeg is en al lank le, is daar maar min aroma aan hom.

diepsee, die mozzies "maasbankers" kan regtig met tye stink, net Nadat hulle gevang is op sabiki's.

later in die livewell vang jy hulle sommer met die hand want die slym is af.

so, kom ons terug na jou vraag:
ek dink aas wat uit die see uit kom, sal n beter olie gehalte he asook meer.
so waarskynlik n beter aas wees.

maar regte aas, regte tyd en plek en jou arms gaan gerek word.
sterkte
 

RuanJ

Member
Willem

Ek waardeer opreg jou opinie en raad. Op die einde van die dag is 'n aas in die water beter as een wat nie is nie.

Ja al lê 'n aas lank en lyk goed, sal ek vervang omdat 'n mens konstant wil "chum" d.m.v bloed en olie en dus groter kans staan vir daai pull.

Nou soek ek graag 'n groot pylstert haha ((goodp_
 
Daar is verskil tussen n kaapse geelstert en n oeskus een. The kaapse een het baai meer oils. But does it make a difference? I dont catch sharks, but when I put a bait bloody bait out that nothing else can fit in their mouths and wait it out eventually a shark eats it. So I figure it makes no difference. I do though know some shark fishermen and the best can drive up for one day to a spot and catch a huge shark and then drive back knowing when to be there so I figure that makes more difference. When to gooi that bait where, and make it bloody and big.. And farmed probably cheaper so win.

I got a spot..if you put a huge bait out at night and put chokka guts in it and let the ink break just before you cast you WILL pick up a huge pylie. So more to it ;) Spot..and when..and bait..chum ja.. always helps.
 

Serra Moz

Sealiner
Perhaps a factor or 2 to pondering about, will be their diet, meaning for the actual legit sea dwellers, their diet will be vastly different and a variety - also they have "hunt" for their chow, as opposed to fish growning up "oppie vis plaas" and getting their daily grub (stock standard type feed) on a golden platter - no "hunting involved - hence, I would assume as stated, different texture / oils / blood / smells.

Consider this, referring to fresh water fish, Carp - years ago I had Carp from different rivers or dams... depending on the preparation of the fish, the "natural" carp will have a bit of a muddy taste. Then, I had farmed Carp at work...tasted good. So I guess it this good perhaps be used as a benchmark?
 

RuanJ

Member
@ Dr HH Jis dankie vir jou opinie en reply!

Mens kan die beste aas hê, maar op die wal beteken dit niks, want die ou met swakker kwaliteit staan steeds 'n beter kans want hy is in die WATER.

You have a spot you say? ;) I wouldn't mind joining haha

Lekker discussion and would love some more experienced guys that really fish HARD share their opinions.

@Serra Mmhmm interesting. Another thing which makes sense to me is that the local tail etc. has natural predators ( In this case the sharks we target) ..

So I'm sure this might assist in a better strike rate as compared to a foreign type of bait fed by those that breed them.

Lekker manne ...keep them coming! I appreciate all the input._seal1_((goodp_
 
Sharks are the clean up crew of the sea..look at nature doccies about when a whale dies, how long does it take to decompose? The sharks chow it before then..they smell it miles away and pull in.. Bait is key but place and time to throw it, like all fishing more key..Throw anything infront of a hungry fish and chances are he will chow it. Sharks are the least fussy of them all.

My mate got a chunk of a washed up whale, took it to mazeepa at the right time and got a 300kg/500lb+ shark, sent it back and came back home..LOL that is the way to do it..in, out, bang..He is a professional fishing guide though with ex national colours, knows his stuff.. You should come visit and book a day with him..Now then you will learn..He uses farmed yellowtail too..Seen him float a mullet out on balloons and pick up bronzies that were nearly 3m long...ja know what to do when and where is the key..bait, if it is big, and bloody and oily and in the water you are halfway there..other half is where and when..My one mate will be at a spot, one day we will be there catching leeries, one day katonkel, others getting leeries and hammerheads on slide mullets, then the next day when the weather goes shocking and water goes cold, he will be there rod bent on a bronzie with a client in tow.. He has written articles also in mags like RS&D I think so look in back issues..bru the fish not fussy as you make out :)

Get enigma to chime in..you got one of the most experienced shark guys in the country as a mod here..Me I chase edibles but it is all the same really, catching a fish so same stuff applies.

In addition, as far as I know the farmed yellowtail comes from NZ/Auz and as far as I know they are one of the major buyers of our export sardine catch..which is used as food for the yellowtail farms there among others..The oil content on those farmed fish is probably very high and they probably taste good. Look at the flake of the belly meat, you can see the lines of fat between the meat flake very easily in oily fish, the cape fish can be 2-3mm thick fat lines between 5mm thick meat flake in the belly, oily as anything, whereas the leaner east coast fish for example the fat line is 1mm wide but meat flakes much thicker 1cm plus in larger fish. Look at the farmed fish and eat one..check it out.I mean for bait..hell..it should not make too much of a difs. Also if buying bait..why not catch it yourself..wait till the reports are thick of fish biting and take a charter out and go catch your own fish, once you catch your limit of 10 katonkel on light spinning gear with the water boiling around you on a boat, you'll never look back..faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarkin addictive fishing that is..running and gunning after little tunas with a tiny tin spoon and 20lb rig..eish..too too, too much fun, and in between a tail grabs you and revs you proper..few things more fun in life as far as I am concerned..
 

RuanJ

Member
I will definitely like to have a chat to him if possible?

Yes I agree with you, if they are hungry they will most probably take the bait.

"You should come visit and book a day with him..Now then you will learn"- Anytime! Let me know how to get in contact!

I would really like to hear Enigma's take on this as I value his opinion immensely. :)
 
Top