
Times have changed from when people here would be jumping down everyones throats..I agree with Sparra and also magnum..Nice to keep it civil and also nice to respond to inquiring criticism so diplomatically..
Times have also changed from when the stock was collapsed, more and more people are returning fish, more and more are returning large fish which is the most important thing we as anglers these days can do..As sparra said things are getting better, they caught more than they kept and also more are being responsible and releasing resident breeding stock. The stock is improving over all as far as I can tell.
In the days that collapsed the stock, farmers treknetted the bays for galjoen to dry on racks of hundreds and thousands of fish to feed the staff during the time the flocks were at the coast. People could freely drive up and down the beaches too and they did and filled their cooler boxes and boots with gallies. I remember seeing fish boxes after fish boxes of gallies growing up and ate my fair share on the braai, those were all sold commercially back then, caught by ous with their bakkies, cooler box after cooler box, this was in Joburg! The gallies got plundered in the old days, at least in that respect, times have changed.
Gallies still take a hammering but there are enough breeding fish in the sea now for the stock to improve and improve. More than there has been in 30 years I'd take a guess at! The more we release big resident breeding fish the sooner we get there and more and more people do these days. A government hatchery feeding spawn into the ocean would also help speed things along. The Galjoen hatchery breeding and it's potential as an aquaculture species has already been explored and mapped as far as I know and it is very suitable to artificial stocking as far as I know was the conclusion.
But ja there is at least a balance today with not everyone people filling streepsakke and lots releasing so at least the stock is improving slowly. Rod and line from the shore on slow growing and resident species has been shown to be responsible for collapse of species here for sure, and one must always take the basin effect into account which means when one is fishing remote places with good stocks that are difficult to get to, it will always seem like the stock is in good shape while in fact it may very well not be, one must be conservative with what one keeps in those areas as it is those stocks at the still full "plug holes" of the basin the have the potential to fill the basin and overflow stock to other areas that are fished out.
To second pylstert, ja there is a wealth of study in SA, particularly ones that deal with galjoen that show the effect of rod and line pressure from the shore on stocks and CPUE (catch per unit effort) and how that stock density goes right up and has almost recovered to pristine levels in marine reserves like de hoop. In those areas the density of mature adult fish averages one fish per foot of coastline, in areas with fishing pressure that drops right down to a fraction of that. Right now it is those areas that are restocking the fished out areas.