Thanks for the link,
Reefman!
Will study the article ...
Wonder, though, just how real life experience in actual fishing situations stacks up against machine testing knots or "lab" statistics ...
Variations in individual style when making the knots and connections could also play a role as would fishing styles (initial and other drag settings) and tackle used (S or E Glass, graphite or composite rods, taper of rods, jerky or smooth drags) and the quarry pursued (fast running and hard hitting fish such as tuna) ...
Also boils down to what one has confidence in from personal experience.
Feedback from other anglers as to their personal experiences may be enlightening too (on a one-to-one basis or "trawling" though the various fishing forums online), especially if this seems to reinforce/ confirm or even cast doubt on, your own personal experience ... The bottom line (excuse the pun) if you are losing (or have lost) fish through knot failure or unexplained line breakage, is that there is a problem that must be solved.
For about the last 7 years, I have fished braid (
Berkley Whiplash - not yet the
Pro version - with a mono leader) on all my fishing set-ups (Surf, Bass, general freshwater) and have not yet lost a fish due to knot failure or line breakage. I have been bitten off by toothy characters when not using wire, I have had hooks straightened out when using braid straight through (initially) with no mono leader, but no knot failure or line breakage. On occasion, when having to deliberately break off after getting stuck on the bottom, for example, its a real chore when you deliberately have to break the line. (The easist way to do this is by winding the braid around a smooth short section of wooden broomstick and walking or pulling back ...).
I have used the
Uniknot with the line doubled when doing the knot ever since the early 1980's after seeing an artcle on the Uniknot System in a 1982 Field and Stream magazine ... Of late, I have also used the 3 loop
Centauri knot. On occasion I have tried the
Palomar in heavy mono (60 - 80lb test). All these knots have performed well, also the Uni - Centauri braid to mono join I descibed in my previous post ... Even the back to back Uni joining mono to mono or braid to mono, has worked well for me ... But then I have not yet beached a 100kg Raggie or Bronzie!
Let's hear some real-life experiences (losing big ones or the PB of a lifetime or just any fish) with the various knots out there - knot failure or breakages that can , most likely, be attributed to the knot. None such for me with the Uniknot even though the machine test stats do not seem to agree ...
By the way, I am not sponsored by the Uniknot Corporation (Joke!)
I also found a link to the
PR Knot (which
Nepptune seems to like so much!):
http://www.jigsdirect.com/eMerchantPro/pc/fishing_knots.asp
Only disadvantage seems to be you need a special little tool/ bobbin to tie this knot.
Thanks again to
Reefman and all the other
Sealiners for this Forum and all the info and experiences you all share!
