Relocating of Carp

MadCarper

Sealiner
Really Jake? lol...

If you read the article you will see that the Harties Fisheries ppl assisted, and they have the necessary permits. And they moved the fish.

So tell us why you felt you had to post this? I'm curious.
 

KUSAF

Senior Member
Jake.

These fish were moved ages ago to Homestead dam that is 1km upstream from where they were moved from.

Did you read the post?
 

Jake1

Senior Member
lets agree that we wont allways agree. I am objective- Carp isnt everything for me allthough I like catching them as well. Carp is and will for allways be a foreign invading fish in South Africa.

I dont have a problem when Carp is relocated to private dams that has no access to Natural rivers where there is for example yellowfish, Kurper -indeginous fish that is supposed to be there.
 

Jake1

Senior Member
MadCarper wrote:
Really Jake? lol...

If you read the article you will see that the Harties Fisheries ppl assisted, and they have the necessary permits. And they moved the fish.

So tell us why you felt you had to post this? I'm curious.
Why I posted this..........Because its a discussion group! LOL try not to be an idiot............lol ok youre not an idiot
 

gt40

Senior Member
Jake u should rather ask why south africa not doing anything thing regarding asian and grass carp which have a major effect on the eco system
 

iggy

Sealiner
Jake1 wrote:
MadCarper wrote:
Really Jake? lol...

If you read the article you will see that the Harties Fisheries ppl assisted, and they have the necessary permits. And they moved the fish.

So tell us why you felt you had to post this? I'm curious.
Why I posted this..........Because its a discussion group! LOL try not to be an idiot............lol ok youre not an idiot
Making a illegal comment when the move where in fact legal is idiotic...sry you no idiot either!
 

Jake1

Senior Member
iggy wrote:
Jake1 wrote:
MadCarper wrote:
Really Jake? lol...

If you read the article you will see that the Harties Fisheries ppl assisted, and they have the necessary permits. And they moved the fish.

So tell us why you felt you had to post this? I'm curious.
Why I posted this..........Because its a discussion group! LOL try not to be an idiot............lol ok youre not an idiot
Making a illegal comment when the move where in fact legal is idiotic...sry you no idiot either!

If the move was legal I cant say much...................... I am just pro-indeginous fish, I wish we were more that felt the same and not so many biased people just because they catch Carp.

Illegal comment...........eish thats a new term I wasnt aware of.
 

MadCarper

Sealiner
Ok Jake we'll agree you're an idiot.

gt40, Jake is not interested in that. He enjoys taking the p&ss out of the specimen carp forum by posting nonsensical posts like this one. You go Jake, lol!
 

Jean77

New member
They were relocated to the venue jake,before that happened there were carp already in there.please clarify what your concern is about?maybe then you wil get an answer
 

Jake1

Senior Member
MadCarper wrote:
Ok Jake we'll agree you're an idiot.

gt40, Jake is not interested in that. He enjoys taking the p&ss out of the specimen carp forum by posting nonsensical posts like this one. You go Jake, lol!
LOL Pathetic if thats all you can say................LOL
 

kaboem

Sealiner
Do you guys even know why we had to move the carp??

All this was done above board and with all the permission required from the relevant authorities.

NO fly by night operations here!!

Geeslike Spinedok what went wrong??? ASFN treating you very well i see...LOL

 

 

 
 

Jake1

Senior Member
Jean77 wrote:
They were relocated to the venue jake,before that happened there were carp already in there.please clarify what your concern is about?maybe then you wil get an answer

My question was, if it was a legal relocation, seems like it was. Like I said if it was legal I cant say much.

Hey guys I just have/had some questions if you read the original post you will see. I am just pro indeginous thats all my friends.
 

Jean77

New member
Maybe he should just read the whole article first.or jake do you think it would have been the right thing to do to leave the fish to die?
 

kaboem

Sealiner
Jake1 wrote:
Jean77 wrote:
They were relocated to the venue jake,before that happened there were carp already in there.please clarify what your concern is about?maybe then you wil get an answer

My question was, if it was a legal relocation, seems like it was. Like I said if it was legal I cant say much.

Hey guys I just have/had some questions if you read the original post you will see. I am just pro indeginous thats all my friends.

No Worries Jake1,

Just wanted to make sure everybody is on the same page. But all was done in good faith and as i said with all the permission needed.

Have a lekker weekend boys!!

Go well!!
 

Jake1

Senior Member
Jean77 wrote:
Maybe he should just read the whole article first.or jake do you think it would have been the right thing to do to leave the fish to die?

like I said I just had some questions regarding the moving of the fish.

If you have no permits to move the fish unfortunately you must let them die, remember I said unfortunately. Dont kill the messenger, but it sounds like they had permits.
 

MadCarper

Sealiner
Jake1 wrote:
MadCarper wrote:
Ok Jake we'll agree you're an idiot.

gt40, Jake is not interested in that. He enjoys taking the p&ss out of the specimen carp forum by posting nonsensical posts like this one. You go Jake, lol!
LOL Pathetic if thats all you can say................LOL

Not nearly as pathetic as this topic you started, lol. t(((up((
 

Jake1

Senior Member
MadCarper wrote:
Jake1 wrote:
MadCarper wrote:
Ok Jake we'll agree you're an idiot.

gt40, Jake is not interested in that. He enjoys taking the p&ss out of the specimen carp forum by posting nonsensical posts like this one. You go Jake, lol!
LOL Pathetic if thats all you can say................LOL

Not nearly as pathetic as this topic you started, lol. t(((up((
LOL I just had some questions, most of them were answered thanks to Kaboem and others, saying a thread with questions is pathetic...................eish, what is this forum for then?

Pathetic..................lolpwf__+
 
Top